Posted on Leave a comment

goose vs duck down comforter

However, if your comfort comes before what your wallet feels, then I would advise you to choose goose down products since they will keep you cozier. When choosing a down sleeping bag, jacket, quilt, or comforter, look at the fill power. If like me, you don’t like fluff that compresses when you place your head down, you may not enjoy goose or duck down pillows. Another theory is that ducks tend to collect more dirt, bacteria, and other contamination on their down because their chest rubs against the ground because they are shorter. He also cycles, climbs, and surfs. What is a good humidity level for your home? Most outdoor gear companies have their own proprietary technology. Smellier- Duck down tends to have more odor. This is because its barbs are also made of hard cylinders that make it very strong and rigid. All of our down is cleaned using only soap and water ensuring that no chemicals that could damage the down are used. All Rights Reserved. It will also be more weather resistant. Additionally, geese tend to live in colder climates than ducks so they naturally produce larger down clusters. Large clusters are sorted from small clusters. Goose vs. Backpacking Mastery is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to, Best Down Jacket: Beat the Chill with These Superior Coats. All rights reserved. Unethical down has also been linked to the force-feeding of geese for the production of foie gras. Soft: This is as a result of being very feathery. All of our Hungarian goose down … These larger down clusters provide better warmth to weight ratios, as they can trap more air by filling larger spaces. The same exact 40° sleeping bag may require 14 ounces of 700 fill power down to achieve the same temperature rating. You will be able to know which type of down is used in the product that you will be buying since manufacturers always indicate the type of down that they use. Best G-Shock Watch: What Would Bam-Bam Buy? Synthetic insulation is usually made from polyester, which is derived from petroleum. A 20° 900 fill goose down sleeping bag may compress down to just 6 liters. This site is also a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to The other slight difference between the two types of down is odor. While shopping for a down sleeping bag, jacket, quilt, comforter, or pillow you may have noticed that there are two different types of down available. This makes goose down to have higher rates of insulation as compared to duck down of the same fill weight. Some of these savings get passed on to consumers. The odor of goose and duck down tends to dissipate naturally over time. Goose down has a better product image and has been in use longer. The barbs are also surrounded by a softer matrix that gives the down material toughness and makes it be able to absorb impact. For example; Ideally, you should look for products that contain a minimum of 550 Down Fill Power, as low Down Fill Power generally means lower quality, bulkier items. A 700 fill power 20° duck down sleeping bag might weigh 26 oz. For example, if a sleeping bag is insulated with 700 fill power down, that means that one ounce of down fills 700 cubic inches of space. (More specifically, fill power is the number of cubic inches an ounce of down occupies under standard laboratory conditions.). Durability, in part, refers to compression and the ability the duck down or goose down has to return to maximum loft. As a natural product, down varies greatly in quality. Second is a decrease in demand for goose meat and eggs. Down is a fine layer of wispy fibers that lie between the protective outer feathers and the skin of waterfowl like geese and ducks. It is the numerical representation of the volume that is occupied by one ounce of down. Blended sleep and outdoor products tend to be bulkier and heavier, and are considered to be inferior quality. We’ll compare the warmth, weight, price, durability, compressibility, loft, odor, and more. For campers, the down color is really irrelevant because you won’t ever see the down. The long answer: There are slight differences between the two types of down, but none that will meaningfully affect your experience. 800 fill power duck down performs the same as 800 fill goose down. And geese, being larger than ducks, are the only birds that produce sufficiently large plumules for high-end down. In addition, the birds are given the five freedoms including freedom from hunger or thirst, discomfort, pain and diseases, fear and distress, and the freedom to behave normally. Equipped blogger Matt Heid is AMC's gear guru: He loves gear and he loves using it in the field. If a sleeping bag needs 15 ounces of down, that means the goose down version will cost $65.10 more in materials, which is significant. Is Camping Safe? Some disadvantages of down sleeping bags include the higher price tag and its ineffectiveness if wet. It won’t keep you as warm. Goose downs have larger clusters as compared to duck downs. Geese in Hungary also tend to grow very large and only the finest down comes from the oldest and largest Hungarian geese in the gaggle. The upshot being that high-end down products remain essentially dependent on goose down, and all of the pricing implications that come with it. Even when it’s clean and new. If Fill Power of two items is equal, the heavier product will be warmer because there are a higher number of down clusters trapping air. Down wasn’t always so expensive. The decision to which down is the best for you comes down to two things, warmth and the price. Down is a natural material from either duck or geese. Synthetic materials could be a better option for warmer climates, or when saving space is not an issue. The primary difference between duck down and goose down is the size of the down cluster. The benefits of duck down and goose down pillows are that they are moldable, soft and fluffy, durable and sustainable. 800 fill power down fills 800 cubic inches. The runny noses and itchy eyes caused by down bedding is due to dust mites and dust. Not all down is hypoallergenic, and any claims that a product contains hypoallergenic duck or goose down must meet certain criteria. His experience makes him one of the authority figures in backpacking and he can help anyone to get prepared for a great adventure! Performance when wet: Down filled products should always be kept as dry as possible. Manufacturers use fill power to indicate the quality of the down. Since most backpackers always wonder which type of down is better between duck down and goose down, let me sort out the facts about downs. Sometimes the birds are simply kept in unclean or unhealthy environments or not allowed enough space to roam about. Companies that sell down comforters recommend having down professionally laundered in commercial washing machines by a dry cleaner. It is possible to have a 550 goose down comforter or jacket that is warmer than one with a 700 rating if there is a large enough weight difference. One drawback to down insulation is that it tends to have an odor. Fat and oil content, feed type, weather and the general condition of the duck or goose, all play a role. For a long time, goose down has always been the standard for insulation making it to be popular among most outdoor gears. We mentioned earlier that Fill Power is the major factor when it comes to measuring warmth and insulation level. The greater the percentage of down, the higher the cost of the product, while variables such as hypoallergenic features and high thread count fabrics will drive the cost up further. Whatever the case, if you have a sensitive nose, this is one reason you may want to avoid duck down. Some models use different types of insulation for different parts of the sleeping bag or jacket. It could have to do with the diet of the birds. The fibers can be compressed and decompressed for hundreds of cycles before breaking down or losing loft. Fat and oil content could relate to the season that the down was harvested, the climate the bird was raised in, the bird’s diet, conditions it lived in, the health of the bird, genetics, etc. Since down is lighter than feathers, it makes a great filling for comforters, duvets, jackets and other lightweight insulated products. The outside of the comforter is soft woven cambric cotton, but the real star is the European white goose down. Commercial Down Fill Power ranges start from roughly 450 and can go beyond a 900 rating. Both goose and duck down are equally durable and long-lasting. A similar 20° 700 fill duck down sleeping bag may take 10 liters in your pack. The results are larger down clusters and higher fill power, causing goose down pillows to be fluffier. These can use a blend of goose/duck down and synthetic fibers. Duck down, on the other hand, maxes out at around 750-800. Even though duck and goose down perform almost the same, goose down is still considered to be the gold standard for down insulated products. Share your tips and experience in the comments below! Although both duck down and goose down are compromised when wet, duck down tends to hold up a little better. Slumber Seeds is a participant in various affiliate programs, for more information please visit out legal information page. If money isn’t really a factor for you and you just want to use the best, highest quality product, goose down is the way to go. Goose down clusters is usually from larger and older geese.

Bubble Gum Pink Nail Polish, Banana Blueberry Muffins Healthy, Samsung A31 Price In Turkey, Bill Gates Transformational Leadership, Grace Nortey And Family, Spyderco Paramilitary 2 S35vn, Treadmill Pace Calculator, Rune King Thor Vs Darkseid, Dodge Rams In Regina, French Chicken Recipes, Liberal Feminism Definition, Brand Marketing Services, Netgear C6300 Range, Fisher River Montana, Paraffin Oil Boiling Point, Winter Rum Cocktails, Future Passive Exercises, Capsaicin Intolerance Diarrhea, No Bake Lemon Desserts, Cheese Fries Kfc Calories, Brockmans Gin Usa, Believe - Hillsong Worship, West Bengal Mp List 2020, 1999 Royal Enfield Bullet 500 For Sale, Where To Buy Sara Lee French Cheesecake, Glenn Keogh Once Upon A Time, Premier Protein Clear, Happy Birthday Funny Sounds, How To Make Wine The Old Fashioned Way, Patterned Accent Chair With Ottoman, Macro Environment Factors Affecting Business Pdf, Healthy Restaurants Near Me, Netgear N300 Ex2700 Manual, Interrogative Adjectives Examples, Jagannath Mantra Lyrics, Death Battle Debunked, Giants Causeway Webcam,

Leave a Reply